What Do I Do When Told to Have a Tooth Extracted?
Get a Second Opinion
Unfortunately, in today’s environment with implants being available, patients are told to have teeth extracted and replaced with implant supported crowns. Although we are very experienced with implant restoration (over 2,500 implants inserted and restored in our office), I will always try to save a tooth rather than extract, if our patient so desires, as demonstrated by the following example.
Consider Restoration Before Extraction
When you’re told that a tooth needs to be extracted, it’s natural to feel concerned about your options. Modern dentistry has advanced significantly, and often there are alternatives to extraction that can preserve your natural tooth structure. Natural teeth, even if compromised, often have advantages over implants or other replacement options. They have natural nerve endings that provide sensation, they integrate with your jaw in ways that implants cannot, and they preserve the natural anatomy of your smile.
Before accepting an extraction recommendation, it’s wise to seek a second opinion from a prosthodontist who specializes in both preservation and restoration techniques.

Fig. 1: Unsatisfactory Existing Crowns
Our patient presented with a desire to replace her crowns which were not aesthetically pleasing (Fig. 1, arrow). Unfortunately, unbeknownst to her, she had extensive decay leaving very little tooth structure upon which to place a crown (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2: Extensive Decay Beneath Crown
Although many dentists would recommend extraction and replacement with implants, we were able to reconstruct the tooth abutments and fabricate two very natural looking crowns. This conservative approach preserved her natural teeth while achieving excellent aesthetic results that have endured.
Tooth extraction is sometimes necessary, but it should be the last resort, not the first option. If you’ve been told you need an extraction, schedule a consultation with Dr. Marlin to explore all your possibilities.
See How We Resolve These Problems
Our patient success stories show real cases and real results. Browse outcomes from a specialist prosthodontist with decades of experience and 3,900+ implants placed.
Related Patient Success Stories
Explore similar patient success stories demonstrating our expertise in advanced prosthetic dentistry.
Before
After Implant Supported Reconstruction: Failing Bridgework and Missing Back Teeth Rebuilt with Coordinated Specialist Care
Referred by another dental specialist with severe bone resorption on the upper left, multiple broken-down lower teeth requiring extraction, and failing lower back teeth that had left the bite without solid support. No single procedure, and no single provider working alone, could rebuild a situation this interconnected.
Before
After Severe Restorative Breakdown Rebuilt with a Coordinated Full-Mouth Reconstruction
Multiple older restorations placed at different times over many years, broken-down teeth, a significant malocclusion, an asymmetrical smile, and two upper front teeth that could no longer be saved. No single repair could address a pattern this widespread.
Before
After How a Loose Upper Bridge and Aging Crowns Were Rebuilt with Staged Implant Reconstruction
A patient referred by her general dentist after years of aging dentistry no longer holding up. A loose upper bridge and crowns more than twenty years old, combined with the effects of advanced periodontal disease and severely compromised tooth abutments, required a staged surgical and restorative plan delivered with comfort planning at the same time.
Related Articles
Deepen your knowledge with additional insights on this topic.
Dental Implants If a Single Front Tooth is Replaced with an Implant, can it Look Natural?
A single front tooth implant can look completely natural with precision placement, custom abutments, and hand-crafted porcelain crowns. Washington, DC.
Dental Implants What is Precision Implant Placement (PIP)?
Learn what Precision Implant Placement (PIP) is and how meticulous planning ensures optimal implant positioning for long-lasting results in Washington, DC.
Dental Implants What is the ideal Surgical Guide for Precision Implant Placement?
CBCT-based surgical guides allow virtual implant planning for precise positioning in optimal bone, ensuring predictable results in Washington, DC.